Pizza from brick oven

HOMETOWN PIZZERIA

Big Apple Flavor. Amish Country Heart

A family legacy expanding from 2 to 12 locations across Ohio's Amish Country and Cedar Point

  OHIO FOOD CRITIC GIVES US HIGH PRAISE     VOTED BEST PIZZA IN AMISH COUNTRY     AUTHENTIC NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA  

Our Story

A family vision built on tradition, quality, and time together

The Miller Family Legacy

Steve Miller, already a successful construction and remodeling entrepreneur, launched the Hometown Pizzeria vision with a purpose deeper than profit — to spend more time with his children. Today, four of his five children keep Hometown Pizzeria's restaurants running, working side by side with their parents.

Hometown Pizzeria is run by the Miller family, working together for decades — not chasing a trend, but building something meant to last. The Millers currently operate two profitable pizzerias with uncommon margins. Expansion is the next chapter.

Trained in Staten Island, NY

Formally trained in the art and science of authentic New York style pizza production, bringing true NYC flavor to Ohio's heartland.

Authentic New York Style Pizza Making
Pizza Cooking School Staten Island

Dedicated to Traditional Service and Quality

This isn't a "family restaurant." It's a family-built operation with a clear vision to expand to 10 locations, while keeping pizza quality consistent in each and every location.

Turnover is low because the leaders are owners, not renters. They don't just manage shifts — they protect the culture and the numbers.

Crafted with Passion

Every pizza tells a story of dedication and authentic flavor

Signature calzones
Specialty pizza from brick oven
Supreme pizza coming out of the oven

How We Make Pizza Magic

The authentic New York way, every single time

🍞

Step 1: The Dough

Made fresh daily from our secret recipe. Hand-stretched to perfection, never rolled. The foundation of great pizza starts here.

🍅

Step 2: The Sauce

Authentic NY-style tomato sauce made from San Marzano tomatoes. The perfect balance of sweet and savory.

🔥

Step 3: Brick Oven

800°F stone hearth creates that perfect crispy-yet-chewy crust with leopard-spotted char. Pure perfection in 90 seconds.

What People Are Saying

Real reviews from real customers who made the trip

★★★★★

"Absolutely amazing New York style pizza, quick and polite service. Also had an Old World Margherita pizza that was perfect. Bring your family and tell your friends about this little gem hidden in plain view."

— Martin Troyer

★★★★★

"We ordered the Smokin' Table Rock pizza and we were absolutely delighted. The best and most flavorful pizza we have ever had. We are visiting from Florida — you need to check them out!!!"

— Robert L. Barron Jr.

★★★★★

"We were in Amish Country for a weekend getaway and decided to try Table Rock Pizza. Probably some of the best pizza we've ever had. Plus the garlic knots were amazing! You should get Dave Portnoy to come review — it would be a great review I'm quite sure!"

— Harris

★★★★★

"Some of the best pizza I've ever had."

— Brad & Sheila

★★★★★

"10/10 — staff was helpful and kind. Food was excellent and delicious. Will come again."

— Kalan

★★★★★

"This was my first time ordering from Kidron Pizza for a work lunch. I had the Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo. I thought it was excellent. Everyone enjoyed it."

— Kidron Pizza Customer

★★★★★

"Good Pizza in Amish Country — good friendly service, great price, and they have other menu choices too."

— Amish Country Visitor

What Google Reviewers Say

Real reviews from real customers

★★★★★

4.9 out of 5 stars

Based on Google Reviews

Read Table Rock Reviews on Google Read Kidron Reviews on Google

Order Online Now

Choose your location and get your pizza delivered or ready for pickup

Table Rock Pizzeria

Berlin, Millersburg, Sugar Creek Area

WED-THURS: 11AM-8PM
FRIDAY: 11AM-9PM
SATURDAY: 11AM-7PM
SUN-TUE: Closed

Order from Table Rock

Kidron Pizzeria

Kidron, Dalton, Apple Creek, Orrville Area

TUES-SAT: 10AM-8PM
SUN-MON: Closed

Order from Kidron

Meet The Millers

Five decades of combined experience, one shared vision

The Miller Family

Steve & Crystal Miller

Founders & Daily Operations

Married for 35 years, Steve and Crystal oversee daily financial and restaurant operations. Steve still owns a successful construction company and started Hometown Pizzeria to spend more time with his children and Crystal — Hometown's Girl Friday.

Anthony 'Tony' Miller

General Manager

The oldest and only son, Tony runs day-to-day operations. Trained formally in Staten Island, NY in the art and science of authentic New York style pizza production, he also owned his own successful flooring business. He understands margins, schedules, and accountability because he's lived them.

Trisha Miller

Production Manager

Trained formally in Staten Island, NY alongside Tony, Trisha personally oversees all dough and sauce production, ensuring consistency every day. She practically grew up in food service with experience at a bakery and jelly manufacturing company as a teenager.

Brittany Miller

Location Manager

The second child, Brittany brings professional customer service and management experience. She doesn't just manage shifts — she protects the culture and the numbers.

Julie Miller

Primary Trainer

Julie is Hometown Pizzeria's primary trainer — the person who makes sure every new hire can execute to quality standard quickly. Together with Brittany, she anchors leadership at the second location.

Why Amish Country?

One of Ohio's most visited destinations — and we're already there

A Captive, Hungry Audience

Ohio's Amish Country draws over 4 million visitors every year — families, tourists, and travelers from across the country passing through a region with limited quality dining options.

Hometown Pizzeria is already established and profitable in this corridor. The expansion plan targets a 75-mile radius encompassing Ohio's highest-traffic tourist destinations, including Cedar Point — the most visited amusement park in the Buckeye State.

The opportunity isn't to build something new. It's to scale something that's already working.

4M+
Annual Amish Country Visitors
350K
Monthly Visitors
75mi
Expansion Radius
2→12
Location Target

Ohio Expansion Target Area

Table Rock Berlin/Millersburg Kidron Dalton/Orrville Cedar Point Expansion Target Canton Wooster Coshocton Millersburg Current Locations Expansion Targets 75-Mile Radius

The Expansion

From 2 to 12 locations across Ohio's premier destinations

Hometown Pizzeria will expand its current presence within Ohio's Amish Country, which draws over 4 million visitors every year, with further expansion into Cedar Point amusement park — the Buckeye State's most popular tourist attraction.

4M+
Annual Visitors to Amish Country
350K
Monthly Visitors
2→12
Location Expansion Plan
35+
Years Family Experience

Investor Download: Private Placement Memorandum

For investor inquiries, email: info@hometownpizzerias.com

Enter your name and email below — we'll send the PPM directly to your inbox.

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know

Do you deliver?

Yes! You can order delivery through our website at tablerockpizza.com and kidronpizza.com. Delivery areas and fees vary by location.

Do you offer catering for events?

Absolutely! We cater weddings, corporate events, birthday parties, and more. Contact us at info@hometownpizzerias.com for pricing and availability.

What makes your pizza "New York style"?

Our team trained in Staten Island, NY to master authentic techniques: hand-tossed dough, high-gluten flour, San Marzano tomato sauce, and a blazing-hot brick oven that creates the signature crispy-yet-foldable crust New York is famous for.

Do you have gluten-free or vegetarian options?

Yes! We offer gluten-free crusts and plenty of vegetarian options including our Margherita pizza and custom veggie combinations. Just ask when ordering.

Can I buy Hometown Pizzeria gift cards?

Gift cards are available at both locations! Perfect for pizza lovers in your life. Contact us for details.

Get In Touch

Questions, catering, or investment inquiries — we'd love to hear from you

Contact Information

📍
Table Rock Pizzeria
Berlin/Millersburg/Sugar Creek Area, OH
📍
Kidron Pizzeria
Kidron/Dalton/Apple Creek/Orrville Area, OH
🕐
Tuesday – Saturday: 10:00AM – 9:00PM
Sunday & Monday: Closed

Connect With Us

Follow our journey on Instagram

Order Online Now